By Søren Roest Korsgaard and David Chandler

This insight into the oft-repeated “whisper” at the end of CeeCee Lyles’s phone call from Flight 93
arose out of a conversation between us on the Telegram app and is an example of true international
collaboration.

For decades, the final voicemail from 9/11 hero CeeCee Lyles, a Flight Attendant on United Airlines
Flight 93 (UA93), has been a focal point for fringe theories that attempt to discredit the authenticity of
the phone calls from the victims on the hijacked airliners. More broadly, the claim that phone calls
were not authentic is used to advance no-hijacking scenarios.

Ms. Lyles called her husband to inform him that her plane had been hijacked and to express hope that
she would see him again. After she said goodbye, the voicemail continued for another 10 seconds.
During those final moments, she can be heard fumbling to put the seat-back phone back into its holder.
Moments later, there is a ~0.8-second-long faint sound or whisper, which theorists have claimed is
someone saying, “it’s a frame.” What they apparently do not recognize is that the holder for the phone
is quite literally a recessed rectangular “frame,” as shown in Figure 1.

Figure 1: A United Airlines GTE Airphone [1].

Figure 2: A portion of the audio track. The highlighted portion shows Ms. Lyles’ “goodbye” (34.5 seconds) followed by an unsuccessful attempt to hang up the phone at the 35-second mark and then the whisper shortly after. The fumbling continues until the end of the track.

While airphone records show that Ms. Lyles placed the call from row 32 ABC, we don’t know her
exact position. The prolonged fumbling indicates that she may have been reaching awkwardly from the
aisle, or she may not have used the passenger phones before, or perhaps the fumbling was simply due
to stress. In any case, the whisper seems to come from someone else, very likely in response to her
unsuccessful attempt to hang up the phone. That, of course, is speculation, but the sound is faint and
unclear, so every interpretation is inherently speculative, making this faint sound an extremely weak
basis for drawing expansive conclusions.

Because “frame” can be used as slang for “frame-up,” i.e., the act of framing an innocent person,
theorists have long cited the whisper in books and documentaries to push narratives of staged calls and
non-existent hijackings [2]. However, there is no reason to believe this is the intended meaning in this
context. A far simpler and more natural explanation is right in front of them (literally!): a passenger or
crew-member trying to help Ms. Lyles hang up said, in a low voice, “fit the frame,” “in the frame,”
“into the frame,” or something to that effect. In this context, the word “frame” carries its most literal,
everyday physical meaning:

Collins English Dictionary: “an enclosing case or border into which something is fitted” [2].

Dictionary.com: “a structure for admitting or enclosing something” [3].

Britannica Dictionary: “an open structure that holds something (such as glass or a picture)” [4].

Ultimately, the “it’s a frame” theory turns an ordinary mechanical detail into a sinister plot through
pure projection. It is unclear what was said, so that in itself is reason to reject the use of this faint
uncertain sound to conclude the phone call was faked. Ms. Lyles was not Meryl Streep reading from a
script in a studio; she was a flight attendant in the final moments of her life during a real hijacking,
trying to say goodbye to her husband while struggling to click a stubborn Airfone handset back into its
frame.

[1]. Matthew Klint. “My Airfone Adventure on United.” Available at: https://liveandletsfly.com/my-
airfone-adventure-on-united/ [accessed November 2026].
[2]. Collins English. “Definition of ’frame’.” Available at:
https://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/frame [accessed November 2026].
[3]. Dictionary.com. “Frame.” Available at: https://www.dictionary.com/browse/frame [accessed
November 2026].
[4]. The Britannica Dictionary. “Frame.” Available at: https://www.britannica.com/dictionary/frame
[accessed November 2026].

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *